everyday

Chapter 4 - The Firstborn’s Claim

The single syllable echoed through the cavernous foyer, bouncing off the vaulted ceiling and ringing in Ethan’s skull.

It sounded like a child learning to speak for the first time, testing the consonants with difficulty.

Ethan felt the floor tilt beneath his feet as vertigo washed over him.

His baby boy was eight months old; he could barely roll over on his stomach, let alone form complete words.

Yet the voice from the pit sounded unmistakably like a three-year-old child who had been denied water for days.

Ethan pointed the brass flagpole directly at the square opening, his voice cracking with fury and fear.

He screamed into the pit, demanding to know who was playing this sick prank.

The red eyes blinked once, slowly, like the shutters of an old camera.

The voice responded with a chilling, hollow giggle that made Clara begin to pray in rapid, broken Latin.

The voice asked why Ethan had left him down in the dark while holding the replacement child upstairs.

Ethan took a step toward Clara, his eyes wide and bloodshot, demanding to know what the voice meant by a replacement.

Clara buried her face in her knees, refusing to look at him or the hole in the floor.

Ethan lowered the brass pole and grabbed Clara by the collar of her evening gown, hoisting her to her feet with one arm.

He shook her violently, asking what she had done and who was living under his floorboards.

Clara’s lips trembled so hard she could barely articulate her words.

She looked toward the pit, tears streaming freely down her bruised face.

She whispered that Ethan’s father hadn't buried what he was supposed to bury three years ago.

She said that Evelyn hadn't died of natural labor complications; she had died trying to hide the first child from Marcus Carter's medical team.

Ethan’s grip on Clara’s gown loosened in shock.

Three years ago, Evelyn had suffered a catastrophic stillbirth at the Carter private clinic, slipping into a fatal coma two hours later.

Or at least, that was what Marcus and the family doctors had told him when he flew back from London.

Ethan had never been allowed to see the body; his father had insisted on an immediate, sealed cremation due to a fabricated infection risk.

Ethan looked from Clara back to the dark hole in the floor, his stomach turning completely inside out.

From the edge of the square shaft, a soft scraping sound broke the silence.

Five pale, elongated fingers curled over the edge of the Carrara marble.

The skin on the fingers was translucent, revealing bluish-black veins pulsing underneath like spiderwebs.

The fingernails were worn down to the quick, crusted with dried lime and dried blood.

The child's hand was roughly the size of a toddler’s, but the fingers were unnaturally long, jointed like bamboo shoots.

A second hand grasped the opposite edge of the stone tile.

Ethan stepped backward, the brass pole trembling in his grip.

A small, pale forehead emerged from the darkness of the shaft.

The hair on the child’s scalp was sparse, white as cobwebs, clinging damply to a skull that was slightly oversized and misshapen.

Beneath the brow, those glowing crimson eyes fixed directly upon Ethan’s face.

The infant on the bench stopped whimpering entirely, freezing as if sensing an apex predator in the room.

The creature’s mouth stretched into an unnatural, ear-to-ear grin, revealing two rows of tiny, jagged teeth.

May you like

It spoke again, its voice carrying an eerie double resonance, like two voices speaking in unison.

“Daddy… ask her what happened to the first baby.”

Related Stories

Other posts