everyday

Chapter 5 - The Woman I Trusted With My Babies Disappeared—Leaving Behind Something That Terrified

MeElise refused to identify the woman immediately.
Not because she wanted to protect her.

Because she was afraid of accusing the wrong person.

"She called herself Claire," Elise explained. "She came to the charity office the morning after the crash. She said Isabella had been killed and that I should never contact the Caruso family."

"Did she threaten you?"

"She told me that if I cared about the babies, I would disappear."

Detective Shaw asked Elise to describe her.

While they spoke, I returned to the nursery.

Maisie was asleep.

Rosie lay awake, studying the ceiling mobile with the solemn concentration only a baby could possess.

I lifted her carefully.

Her tiny hand closed around my finger.

"I'm sorry," I whispered.

I had spent so much time searching for the person who had taken their mother that I had almost forgotten the two little girls who still needed their father.

Rosie blinked.

Then smiled.

For a moment, the world felt merciful.

That evening, I asked Elise to stay.

Not as an employee awaiting dismissal.

As someone I trusted with the most precious things in my life.

She looked surprised.

"Mr. Caruso, I haven't told you everything."

"I know."

"Then why trust me?"

"Because you keep telling me when you don't know something. Everyone else seems to have an answer prepared."

She looked away.

"Your wife loved you very much."

The words nearly undid me.

At midnight, I went to the chapel with Daniel.

The little building stood at the edge of the estate, its stained-glass windows dark beneath the winter sky.

Inside, I found the wooden pew where Isabella had sat after I proposed.

A crescent moon had been carved beneath its armrest.

The silver key fit a tiny lock underneath.

A hidden compartment opened.

Inside lay a flash drive and a folded letter.

I recognized Isabella's handwriting.

Anthony, if you find this, please don't let grief make your decisions for you.

I pressed the letter against my chest.

When I returned to the mansion, Elise was gone.

Her bedroom was empty.

Her phone lay on the dresser.

Beside it was a photograph of Maisie and Rosie.

On the back, Elise had written:

I didn't leave because I wanted to. They know where my brother lives.

I called Daniel.

"Find her."

Then my phone rang.

Unknown number.

I answered.

A distorted voice said, "You have the drive. We have the nanny."

I gripped the phone.

"What do you want?"

"The original documents. No police. No security."

A pause.

May you like

Then the voice added:

"And Anthony? Ask your brother what happened to the third baby."

Related Stories

Other posts