everyday

Chapter 12 - THE BABY WAS SOLD FOR A FORTUNE—BUT THE WOMAN WHO SIGNED THE PAPERS WASN'T HIS MOTHER!

“HOW MUCH DID THEY PAY FOR MY BROTHER?”
Emily's question struck Richard Bennett like a physical blow.

He stood beside Noah's crib, staring at the adoption document on her phone.

The room was filled with the soft mechanical hum of a white-noise machine.

Outside, rain had begun tapping against the windows.

Richard's hands trembled.

“Emily, please understand that I didn't know what happened until years later.”

She shook her head.

“Then tell me what you learned.”

He looked toward the doorway.

For a moment, Emily thought he was searching for someone to rescue him from the conversation.

But there was nobody left.

Margaret was dead.

Thomas Mercer had already confessed his part in the staged accident.

Patricia was facing criminal proceedings.

Michael was in custody.

And Daniel was living apart from Emily after assaulting her.

Richard had no one left to hide behind.

He lowered himself into the nursery armchair.

“Charles Reynolds paid a private intermediary two hundred and fifty thousand dollars.”

Emily stared at him.

“For a baby?”

Richard nodded.

She felt sick.

“That's not an adoption fee.”

“No.”

“That's trafficking.”

Richard closed his eyes.

“Yes.”

Emily looked down at Noah.

Her son's tiny fingers were wrapped around the edge of his blanket.

She imagined someone carrying him away while a doctor told her he had died.

The thought was unbearable.

Richard continued.

“Charles and his wife had lost their infant son after a serious illness.”

Emily looked up.

“Michael?”

“No.”

Richard swallowed.

“Their biological son was named Andrew.”

Emily felt a chill.

“Then Michael took his place?”

“Not exactly.”

Richard explained that the Reynolds family had been desperate to adopt another child.

Charles possessed enormous wealth and powerful connections.

Eleanor Whitmore knew that Margaret had recently delivered a healthy baby boy.

She also knew Margaret was vulnerable after a difficult delivery.

According to the records Richard later recovered, Eleanor arranged for the child to be removed from the hospital.

Margaret was told Benjamin had died.

Charles was told the child's birth parents had voluntarily surrendered him.

The forged paperwork connected those two lies.

Emily listened in horror.

“So Charles didn't know?”

Richard hesitated.

“At first, perhaps not.”

“What about later?”

Richard looked toward the window.

“Later, he knew enough to understand something was wrong.”

Emily's voice hardened.

“And he kept him anyway.”

Richard nodded.

The answer made her furious.

She understood the pain of losing a child.

But grief did not give anyone the right to steal another family's baby.

She looked at the adoption document again.

“Who forged Mom's signature?”

Richard shook his head.

“I never proved it.”

“Then why did you say the witness was supposed to be dead?”

Richard stared at the floor.

“Because William Carter's signature was copied from a document dated after his reported death.”

Emily frowned.

“William died only a few months ago.”

Richard looked up sharply.

“That's what Daniel told you?”

Emily froze.

“Yes.”

Richard's expression changed.

“Then the date on this record must have been altered.”

He reached for the phone.

Emily handed it to him.

Richard enlarged the scanned page.

The adoption had occurred decades earlier, but the digital certification was recent.

The witness signature had been attached to a later authentication document.

Richard exhaled shakily.

“Someone has combined old records with newer paperwork.”

Emily stared at him.

“To make it look legitimate?”

“Yes.”

She felt another wave of anger.

The message sender had presented the documents as undeniable proof.

But the paperwork itself might be another manipulation.

Emily looked at the screen.

“Then we need the originals.”

Richard nodded.

“And we need independent DNA testing.”

Emily stared at him.

“You don't believe Michael is my brother?”

“I believe Benjamin existed.”

Richard's voice broke.

“I believe someone took him.”

He looked toward Noah.

“But I won't let another forged document decide who our family is.”

The next morning, Detective Mitchell arrived with two investigators.

Emily handed over the messages.

She described the sedan.

She explained Richard's account of Benjamin's birth.

Mitchell listened carefully.

Then she revealed something unexpected.

Michael Reynolds had denied sending the messages.

Emily stared at her.

“He's lying.”

“Possibly.”

“But the photograph showed his watch.”

“That doesn't establish when the photograph was taken.”

Emily felt frustrated.

“Then who sent it?”

Mitchell placed a folder on the table.

“We traced part of the communication through a service used by a private investigation firm.”

Richard looked up.

“What firm?”

“Northbridge Investigations.”

His face changed.

Emily noticed.

“You know them?”

Richard nodded.

“Margaret hired them years ago.”

The room became silent.

Mitchell continued.

“The company closed after its founder disappeared.”

Emily felt a cold sensation.

“Who was the founder?”

“Eleanor Whitmore's former business partner.”

Richard whispered:

“Samuel Price.”

Emily looked at him.

“Who is Samuel Price?”

Richard swallowed.

“A man who helped Margaret search for Benjamin.”

Mitchell opened the folder.

Inside was a photograph of a middle-aged man standing outside a hospital.

He had dark hair and a narrow face.

Emily stared at him.

Something about his expression seemed familiar.

Then she remembered.

She had seen him before.

Not in a photograph.

In person.

At Noah's baptism.

He had stood near the back of the church.

Emily had assumed he was a guest of Daniel's family.

She looked at Mitchell.

“He was there.”

The detective leaned forward.

“Where?”

“At my son's baptism.”

Richard went pale.

Mitchell asked whether Emily had photographs from the ceremony.

Emily nodded.

She opened a folder on her phone.

There were dozens of pictures.

Noah wearing a white christening outfit.

Daniel smiling beside the church altar.

Patricia holding a bouquet.

Michael standing near the stained-glass windows.

And in the background of one photograph, Samuel Price.

Emily enlarged the image.

He was watching Michael.

Not Noah.

Not Emily.

Michael.

Mitchell studied the picture.

“Send me the original file.”

Emily complied.

Richard sat motionless.

His breathing had become shallow.

Emily turned toward him.

“Daddy?”

He looked up.

“Samuel told Margaret he had found Benjamin.”

Emily froze.

“When?”

“Shortly before she died.”

Emily stared at him.

“And?”

Richard's voice trembled.

“He demanded money for the information.”

Emily felt sick.

“How much?”

“Five hundred thousand dollars.”

She shook her head.

“Mom didn't have that kind of money.”

“No.”

Richard looked away.

“But she had something Samuel wanted.”

Emily stepped closer.

“What?”

Richard hesitated.

“The original Blackwater evidence.”

Emily stared at him.

“The documents you collected?”

“Yes.”

She began to understand.

Margaret had possessed information that could expose the construction fraud.

Samuel had offered information about Benjamin in exchange for that evidence.

Emily whispered:

“Did she give it to him?”

Richard shook his head.

“She refused.”

“Why?”

“Because she believed Samuel was working for Evelyn.”

Mitchell looked up.

“Do you have proof?”

Richard nodded slowly.

“Margaret recorded one of their conversations.”

Emily's heart began pounding.

“Where is it?”

Richard looked toward the silver necklace Emily had received in the mysterious package.

“The pendant.”

Emily stared at him.

“What?”

Richard pointed toward the tiny star-shaped charm.

“Margaret used to hide things inside jewelry.”

Emily removed the necklace.

Mitchell examined the pendant.

A small seam ran along its edge.

With careful pressure, the detective opened it.

Inside was a miniature memory card.

Emily stopped breathing.

Richard began crying.

“She kept it.”

Mitchell secured the card for forensic examination.

Several hours later, investigators recovered an audio recording.

Margaret's voice filled the interview room.

“Samuel, I know Benjamin is alive.”

A man's voice answered.

“Then you know what I want.”

Margaret sounded furious.

“You don't get to sell me my own son twice.”

Emily began crying.

Samuel laughed.

“Your husband should have kept his mouth shut.”

Margaret replied:

“Tell Evelyn I'm not afraid of her.”

A pause followed.

Then Samuel spoke again.

“You should be afraid of the woman standing behind you.”

A chair scraped.

Margaret gasped.

The recording ended.

Emily stared at the speaker.

Her mother had been threatened.

Possibly moments before she was attacked.

Mitchell immediately ordered the audio analyzed.

But Richard was staring at the transcript.

His expression had changed.

Emily noticed.

“What?”

He pointed toward one sentence.

“The woman standing behind you.”

Emily frowned.

“What about it?”

Richard whispered:

“Samuel wasn't talking about Evelyn.”

Emily felt cold.

“How do you know?”

Richard looked at her.

“Because Evelyn was in another state that night.”

Emily stared at him.

“Then who was behind Mom?”

Richard closed his eyes.

“The woman who helped deliver Benjamin.”

Emily's stomach dropped.

“Eleanor Whitmore?”

Richard shook his head.

“No.”

He looked directly at her.

May you like

“Patricia Carter.”

And Emily realized the woman who had nearly harmed Noah might have been connected to the disappearance of her brother long before Daniel was born.

Related Stories

Other posts