Chapter 13 - Jonathan Claimed Elizabeth Was Daniel’s Sister—Then Grace Revealed Who Really Gave Birth to the TwinsRain hammered the Maine coast when Daniel arrived at Vale House.

The building stood above black cliffs overlooking the Atlantic, isolated behind pine trees twisted by decades of salt wind. It looked less like a home than a place designed for secrets—gray stone, narrow windows and one road leading in or out.
Daniel brought Rachel.
Emily insisted on coming.
Elizabeth refused to stay behind after Jonathan claimed she was Grace Walsh's daughter.
Daniel wanted her nowhere near danger.
Elizabeth answered simply:
"My identity is inside that house too."
He couldn't argue.
Police surrounded the property from a distance. Daniel would not allow another reckless confrontation when children weren't immediately at risk.
Jonathan had Grace.
That was enough.
Inside, the house smelled of old wood and ocean air.
Jonathan waited beside a fireplace.
Grace sat several feet away.
No restraints.
But fear remained visible in her posture.
Daniel looked at Jonathan.
"Let her leave."
"After we talk."
"Now."
Grace stood.
Jonathan didn't stop her.
She crossed the room.
Daniel caught her shoulders.
"Are you hurt?"
"No."
"Did he force you here?"
Grace looked at Jonathan.
"He threatened Maya."
Daniel's expression hardened.
Jonathan shrugged.
"I needed her attention."
"Threatening family seems to be everyone's favorite communication method."
Jonathan smiled.
"You'll understand eventually."
"No."
Daniel's voice remained calm.
"I won't."
That distinction had become increasingly important.
Understanding why someone became cruel did not require becoming cruel yourself.
Emily entered.
Jonathan stared.
Then Elizabeth stepped beside her.
For the first time, Jonathan lost composure.
"Jesus."
The twins stood together.
Grace began crying.
Daniel turned.
"You know."
Grace nodded.
"Tell us."
She sat.
Her hands shook.
Forty-four years earlier, Grace and her sister Elena Walsh worked briefly at a private reproductive clinic funded by Alexander Sterling.
Grace was nineteen.
Elena twenty-one.
Neither understood the true scope of Crownbridge.
One patient was a young woman named Margaret Pierce.
Daniel frowned.
"Aunt Margaret?"
Richard's sister had used her married name later.
Grace nodded.
Margaret became pregnant with twins.
Not naturally.
The embryos were created through donated genetic material.
Margaret was told she was carrying for an infertile couple.
But after delivery, Crownbridge separated the girls.
One became Emily.
The other Elizabeth.
Emily stared.
"My mother wasn't..."
"The woman who raised you?"
"No."
Grace shook her head.
"She adopted you."
Emily sat down.
Elizabeth remained standing.
"Who were our biological parents?"
Grace looked toward Jonathan.
He smiled.
"No."
Grace continued.
"The egg donor was Elena Walsh."
Maya's grandmother.
Emily stopped breathing.
Elizabeth stared.
"And the father?"
Grace looked toward Alexander's old file on the table.
"Unknown donor."
Jonathan laughed.
"Liar."
Daniel turned.
"You have something to say?"
Jonathan threw a folder onto the table.
The sperm donor was listed.
DAVID COLE.
Rachel went completely still.
Her father.
Thomas Gray.
The former Crownbridge security chief.
Emily stared at Rachel.
If the file was true, Emily and Elizabeth were biological daughters of David Cole and Elena Walsh.
Rachel might be their paternal half-sister.
The family web tightened again, but Daniel refused to accept another decades-old Crownbridge document as truth.
"We test it independently."
Jonathan smiled.
"Finally somebody learned."
Grace looked toward Elizabeth.
"You are not my daughter."
Elizabeth exhaled.
Jonathan's claim had been a manipulation.
"Then why did he say I was?"
"To make Daniel come."
Jonathan didn't deny it.
Daniel's anger sharpened.
"You used incest implications involving my son to get my attention."
Jonathan shrugged.
"I needed leverage."
Emily stepped toward him.
"You're disgusting."
Jonathan smiled.
"Maybe."
Daniel looked at Grace.
"Then what about my father?"
Grace's face changed.
That question hurt her differently.
She explained that she was already involved with Jonathan when Richard approached her about the donor program.
Grace believed she could not become pregnant naturally because of an earlier diagnosis.
Then the clinic collected her eggs.
Richard's sperm was used.
An embryo was created.
But before transfer, Grace discovered she was already pregnant.
Daniel stared.
"So I wasn't the embryo."
Grace shook her head.
"No."
Silence.
Daniel felt the room tilt.
All this time, Crownbridge had treated him as the successful embryo selected to avoid Adam's mutation.
But Grace was saying he had been conceived naturally before the procedure.
"Jonathan."
Grace nodded.
"He may be your father."
Jonathan smiled.
Daniel ignored him.
"What happened to the embryo created with Richard?"
Grace began crying.
"It was transferred."
"To who?"
"Victoria."
Daniel stared.
Victoria had claimed she could no longer safely carry another child.
But apparently she tried.
"What happened?"
"The pregnancy continued."
Daniel stopped breathing.
"Child?"
Grace nodded.
"A boy."
Jonathan's smile disappeared.
Daniel stared.
"Where is he?"
Grace whispered:
"That's who Elias was."
The nursery plaque.
A-04 — ELIAS.
Daniel remembered.
"So Elias is Richard and Grace's biological son."
"Yes."
"And Victoria carried him."
"Yes."
"What happened to him?"
Grace looked toward Jonathan.
"He was taken."
Jonathan answered.
"Crownbridge wanted him because he was the actual selected embryo."
Daniel felt sick.
The child Richard intended to create after Adam's death had survived.
Elias.
Richard's biological son.
Grace's biological son.
Daniel's maternal half-brother.
"Is he alive?"
Jonathan smiled.
"Very."
Daniel stared.
"Where?"
"Closer than you think."
Daniel hated that phrase.
Rachel searched current databases.
No Elias Hawthorne.
No Elias Walsh.
No obvious match.
Jonathan walked toward the window.
"Elias grew up inside Crownbridge."
"Like Elizabeth?"
"Worse."
"Why?"
"Alexander raised him personally."
Elizabeth's face changed.
"I knew Alexander's ward."
Daniel looked at her.
"Name?"
She whispered:
"Edward Sterling."
Vanessa's uncle.
The respected physician who supposedly died ten years earlier.
Daniel almost laughed.
Another identity.
Another death.
"Alive?"
Elizabeth nodded slowly.
"I saw him six months ago."
Daniel stared.
Elias had lived under the Sterling name.
Which meant Alexander had taken Richard's biological son and raised him as family.
"Why does he matter now?"
Jonathan turned.
"Because Alexander wasn't running Crownbridge anymore."
Daniel froze.
"Who was?"
"Elias."
Silence.
Everything shifted.
Alexander had been founder.
Architect.
Manipulator.
But age had weakened him.
Someone younger managed operations.
Someone with Hawthorne blood.
Someone who could access family systems.
Daniel thought of the attack on Alexander's convoy.
His biometric authorization.
The hidden files.
Perhaps they had blamed Samuel too quickly.
"Where is Elias?"
Jonathan looked toward Grace.
"Ask her."
Grace whispered:
"I don't know."
Jonathan laughed.
"You met him three days ago."
Daniel turned.
Grace's face went white.
"Mom."
Grace began crying.
"He came to me."
"Where?"
"Hawthorne Manor."
"When?"
"Before the attack."
"What did he want?"
"You."
Daniel froze.
"Why?"
Grace looked directly into his eyes.
"Because Elias believes Richard stole his life and gave it to you."
Daniel felt cold.
"I didn't even know he existed."
"He doesn't care."
Jonathan moved closer.
"Elias spent his childhood being told you were the mistake and he was the rightful Hawthorne son."
Daniel stared.
"And now?"
"Now he wants the family."
"What does that mean?"
Jonathan smiled sadly.
"Your company."
"Take it."
"Your house."
"Take it."
"Your money."
"Take it."
Jonathan's expression changed.
"He doesn't care about those."
Daniel's stomach tightened.
"Then what?"
"Your children."
Daniel moved instantly.
He grabbed Jonathan by the collar.
"Say that again."
Jonathan didn't resist.
"Elias believes the Hawthorne children belong with the Hawthorne heir."
Daniel shoved him backward.
"They belong with themselves."
Jonathan nodded.
"I agree."
Daniel stared.
For the first time, he believed him.
Rachel's phone rang.
She answered.
Her face changed.
"What?"
Claire's voice came through.
Panicked.
"Daniel, come home."
"What's wrong?"
"Oliver."
His blood froze.
"What happened?"
"He's fine."
Daniel closed his eyes briefly.
"Then what?"
"The DNA results came back."
Everyone went silent.
Daniel looked toward Emily.
Claire continued.
"The advanced maternal test."
Daniel's heartbeat accelerated.
"Emily or Elizabeth?"
Silence.
"Claire."
"Neither."
Daniel stopped breathing.
"What?"
"The lab repeated it three times."
Emily stared.
Elizabeth whispered:
"Impossible."
Claire continued.
"Oliver is definitely Daniel's biological son."
Daniel closed his eyes.
"But his biological mother isn't Emily."
He looked toward Elizabeth.
"And it isn't Elizabeth."
The room became completely silent.
Daniel whispered:
"Then who?"
Claire began crying.
"The database found a maternal match."
"WHO?"
Claire answered:
"Vanessa."
Daniel stared.
No one moved.
The woman who pushed Maya down the staircase.
The woman he nearly married.
The woman who had called Oliver a complication.
Vanessa Sterling.
Daniel felt the floor disappear beneath him.
Then Claire whispered:
"Daniel..."
"What?"
"Vanessa didn't know."
He stared.
"How?"
"The embryo was created years before you met her."
Daniel's face went white.
Crownbridge had used his genetic material.
Vanessa's egg.
Created Oliver.
Then arranged for Natalie to carry him.
Long before Daniel and Vanessa supposedly fell in love.
Their entire relationship might have been constructed after the child already existed.
Daniel looked toward the storm outside.
And suddenly the staircase fall no longer looked like the beginning of Vanessa's plan.
May you like
It looked like the moment Vanessa discovered she had been trapped inside someone else's plan all along.
TO BE CONTINUED...
Related Stories